Ithaca, New York, a vibrant hub nestled in the Finger Lakes region, is known for Cornell University, stunning gorges, and a surprisingly diverse culinary scene. While farm-to-table freshness and international flavors abound, one cuisine often underestimated in this picturesque town is Mexican food. But dig a little deeper, and you’ll discover a hidden world of tacos, enchiladas, and more, waiting to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re a student craving a taste of home, a local seeking a flavorful escape, or a visitor eager to explore Ithaca’s culinary delights, this guide will lead you to the best Mexican restaurants in town, proving that Ithaca’s Mexican food scene is more than just a novelty – it’s a delicious experience waiting to be savored.
From traditional, family-run eateries serving up time-honored recipes to innovative restaurants putting a modern spin on classic dishes, Ithaca offers a Mexican food adventure for every palate and budget. So, prepare your taste buds for a fiesta, because we’re about to uncover Ithaca’s spicy secret!
A Taste of Tradition: Authentic Mexican Gems
For those seeking an authentic taste of Mexico, Ithaca offers several restaurants that have been serving up traditional flavors for years. These establishments pride themselves on using authentic ingredients and time-honored cooking techniques, transporting you straight to the heart of Mexico with every bite.
First up is El Rancho Grande, a local favorite known for its warm atmosphere and generous portions. Located just a short drive from the Ithaca Commons, El Rancho Grande has been a staple in the community for many years. Their menu is packed with classic dishes like enchiladas, burritos, and fajitas, all made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. But their true star is the mole poblano, a rich and complex sauce made with chilies, spices, and chocolate. The mole is simmered for hours to develop its deep, nuanced flavor, and it’s a must-try for any serious Mexican food lover. The restaurant is often bustling with families and students, all enjoying the authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. A recent customer noted, “El Rancho Grande is my go-to spot when I’m craving real Mexican food. The portions are huge, the prices are reasonable, and the food is always delicious.” Beyond the mole, consider trying their carnitas, slow-cooked pork that’s crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. They also offer a wide selection of Mexican beers and tequilas to complement your meal.
Next on our list is La Esperanza Taqueria, a smaller, more intimate restaurant that focuses on authentic tacos. Tucked away on a side street, La Esperanza Taqueria is a hidden gem that’s popular with locals in the know. Their tacos are made with handmade tortillas and filled with a variety of meats, including carne asada, al pastor, and lengua (beef tongue). Each taco is topped with fresh cilantro, onions, and a squeeze of lime. They also offer vegetarian options, such as tacos filled with grilled vegetables or black beans. What sets La Esperanza Taqueria apart is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods. Their meats are marinated overnight to ensure maximum flavor, and their tortillas are made fresh daily. One reviewer shared, “This is the real deal! The tacos are simple but incredibly flavorful. You can tell they use quality ingredients and put a lot of care into their food.” Don’t miss their horchata, a refreshing rice milk drink that’s perfect for cooling down after a spicy meal.
Finally, we have Dos Amigos, a family-owned restaurant that has been serving authentic Mexican food in Ithaca for over a decade. Dos Amigos is known for its friendly service, vibrant atmosphere, and extensive menu. They offer a wide range of dishes, from traditional favorites like tamales and chile relleno to more regional specialties like cochinita pibil (slow-roasted pork marinated in citrus and achiote). They also have a dedicated vegetarian section on their menu, with options like veggie enchiladas and mushroom tacos. The restaurant’s atmosphere is warm and inviting, with colorful decorations and lively music. It’s a great place to gather with friends and family for a festive meal. A loyal customer mentioned, “Dos Amigos is like a little piece of Mexico in Ithaca. The food is always delicious, the service is friendly, and the atmosphere is fun. It’s one of my favorite restaurants in town.” Be sure to try their margaritas, which are made with fresh lime juice and top-shelf tequila.
Beyond Tacos: Modern Takes on Mexican Flavors
While traditional Mexican restaurants offer a taste of authenticity, Ithaca also boasts a few restaurants that are pushing the boundaries of Mexican cuisine, incorporating modern techniques and flavors to create innovative and exciting dishes.
One such restaurant is Agave Kitchen, a stylish and contemporary establishment that focuses on using locally sourced ingredients to create Mexican-inspired dishes. Agave Kitchen’s menu features creative tacos, quesadillas, and salads, all made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their chefs are known for their inventive flavor combinations and beautiful presentations. Their menu changes frequently to reflect the availability of seasonal produce. They take pride in sourcing ingredients from local farms and producers, ensuring that their dishes are as fresh and sustainable as possible. A popular dish is the duck confit tacos, made with slow-cooked duck, pickled onions, and a spicy aioli. They also have a great selection of craft beers and cocktails, including several margaritas made with unique ingredients. “Agave Kitchen is a refreshing take on Mexican food,” said a food critic. “The dishes are creative, the ingredients are fresh, and the atmosphere is chic. It’s a great place to go for a special occasion or a night out with friends.” If you’re feeling adventurous, try their ceviche, which is made with fresh seafood marinated in citrus juice and served with crispy plantain chips.
Another restaurant that’s putting a modern spin on Mexican cuisine is The Spicy Cow. While the name might not immediately scream “Mexican,” this restaurant prides itself on its unique fusion of flavors. The chef has a passion for Mexican cuisine, but he is not afraid to experiment with different ingredients and techniques. Their menu features a variety of tacos, burritos, and bowls, all customizable with your choice of protein, toppings, and sauces. They also offer a selection of creative sides, such as elote (Mexican street corn) and sweet potato fries. The Spicy Cow is a great option for those who want to try something a little different. A frequent diner shared, “The Spicy Cow is my go-to spot for a quick and delicious meal. Their bowls are packed with flavor, and I love that I can customize them to my liking.” One of their most popular items is the Korean BBQ burrito, filled with marinated beef, kimchi, and a spicy gochujang sauce.
Tacos on the Go: Quick & Delicious Mexican Options
Sometimes, you just need a quick and easy bite of Mexican food. Luckily, Ithaca has several options for those who are looking for a fast and delicious meal on the go.
Keep an eye out for the Taco Loco food truck, often parked near Cornell University’s campus. Taco Loco is a popular spot for students and locals alike, serving up classic tacos, burritos, and quesadillas at affordable prices. Their tacos are simple but satisfying, and their burritos are packed with flavor. They also offer vegetarian options, such as black bean tacos and veggie burritos. Taco Loco is a great option for a quick and affordable meal, especially when you are on campus and pressed for time.
Another great option for a quick bite is Miguel’s Arepas, though not strictly Mexican, the Latin American flavors often scratch the same itch. Located inside the Ithaca Public Market, Miguel’s Arepas offers arepas – Venezuelan corn cakes filled with a variety of savory fillings. While arepas are not traditionally Mexican, they share some similarities with Mexican cuisine and are a great option for those who are looking for a quick and satisfying meal. Miguel’s serves a diverse menu of arepas with customizable and vegetarian-friendly options.
Spice it Up: Mexican Drinks and Ambiance
No Mexican meal is complete without a refreshing drink and a vibrant atmosphere. Several restaurants in Ithaca excel in both areas.
For margaritas, look no further than El Rancho Grande. Their margaritas are made with fresh lime juice and top-shelf tequila, and they come in a variety of flavors. They also have a wide selection of Mexican beers and tequilas.
If you’re looking for a lively atmosphere, Dos Amigos is the place to be. Their restaurant is always buzzing with energy, and they often have live music on the weekends. It’s a great place to celebrate a birthday or other special occasion.
For a more romantic atmosphere, Agave Kitchen offers a sophisticated and stylish setting. Their restaurant is dimly lit and decorated with contemporary art, creating a relaxed and intimate ambiance.
Making the Most of Your Mexican Food Adventure
Ready to embark on your Mexican food journey in Ithaca? Here are a few tips to help you make the most of your experience:
Consider making reservations, especially on weekends, as popular restaurants can get busy.
Check for lunch specials or happy hour deals, which can be a great way to sample a variety of dishes at a lower price.
Be open to trying new dishes and flavors. Don’t be afraid to step outside of your comfort zone and order something you’ve never had before.
Ask locals for their recommendations. They’re often the best source of information about hidden gems and local favorites.
Conclusion
Ithaca’s Mexican food scene is a vibrant and diverse culinary landscape, offering everything from traditional, family-run eateries to innovative restaurants putting a modern spin on classic dishes. Whether you’re craving authentic tacos, flavorful enchiladas, or creative Mexican-inspired cuisine, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your taste buds in this charming Finger Lakes town. So, ditch the stereotype of Ithaca as solely a place for farm-to-table eats and discover a whole new world of flavor. Grab your appetite and explore the tastes of Mexico right here in Ithaca – you won’t be disappointed!
