Introduction
Spencerport, New York. The very name conjures images of a picturesque canal town, a haven of tranquility nestled along the historic Erie Canal. While the scenery undoubtedly charms, there’s another, equally compelling reason to visit: its burgeoning food scene. Beyond the quaint shops and scenic bike paths lies a delightful array of restaurants, cafes, and eateries, each offering a unique taste of local flavor. This isn’t just a stopover; it’s a destination for food lovers. So, prepare your appetite, because we’re embarking on a culinary tour of Spencerport, guiding you through the best spots to eat and what to order when you get there. Whether you are a local or just passing through you will find this guide a delightful treat.
Casual Dining and Family Restaurants
Spencerport provides several choices when it comes to family restaurants.
The Village Grill
The Village Grill is a beloved local gathering place, radiating a welcoming atmosphere that’s perfect for families and friends. Its unpretentious charm makes it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal. Think wood paneling, comfortable booths, and the friendly chatter of regulars. But don’t let the casual vibe fool you – the food is seriously good. Their menu is packed with crowd-pleasers, but the burgers are truly legendary. Juicy patties, cooked to perfection and piled high with your favorite toppings, are the stars of the show. From the classic cheeseburger to more adventurous creations loaded with bacon, onion rings, and barbecue sauce, there’s a burger for every palate. And don’t sleep on the wings! Crispy, flavorful, and available in a variety of sauces, they’re the perfect appetizer or a satisfying meal in themselves. Weekends bring breakfast specials that draw a crowd, with fluffy pancakes, hearty omelets, and all the classic breakfast staples. Prices are reasonable, making it an excellent choice for a family meal. The Village Grill also boasts outdoor seating during the warmer months, adding to its appeal. You can find them on Main Street, and they have a website and phone number for easy reservations or takeout orders. They cater to families, and children are welcomed, so bring the whole gang to enjoy the Village Grill.
Spencerport Diner
The Spencerport Diner is a classic diner experience, complete with a retro vibe and a menu that seems to go on forever. You will see it as you cruise down Lyell Ave. Open early for breakfast and serving until late, it’s a dependable spot for a satisfying meal any time of day. From fluffy pancakes and crispy bacon to juicy burgers and comforting meatloaf, the menu is a trip down memory lane of classic American comfort food. The portions are generous, and the prices are affordable, making it a great value. While everything on the menu is solid, the breakfast is especially noteworthy. Their omelets are legendary, packed with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. And the pancakes? Golden brown, fluffy, and drenched in syrup – a true breakfast delight. The diner also offers daily specials, so be sure to check what’s on offer. You can expect a hearty, filling meal at a reasonable price when you stop at the Spencerport Diner.
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Another popular option for families seeking a reliable and tasty experience is a great pizza place like Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria located in town. While Salvatore’s is part of a larger local chain, this location is a family favorite, providing the classic staples expected from a chain with the friendly small-town feel Spencerport is known for. This location provides easy parking and space for families to dine-in together, so you can relax while the kids choose their favorite pie.
Pizza and Italian Options
Sometimes, nothing hits the spot like a slice of pizza. Spencerport boasts options that would make anyone happy.
Papa Joe’s Pizza
Papa Joe’s Pizza is all about New York-style pizza. Think thin, crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and generous amounts of mozzarella cheese. It’s the kind of pizza you can fold in half and devour on the go, a true New York classic. While they offer a variety of toppings, sometimes the simple cheese pizza is the best way to appreciate the quality of the ingredients. Their specialty pizzas are also worth trying, with creative combinations that push the boundaries of pizza perfection. But Papa Joe’s is more than just pizza. They also offer a selection of classic Italian dishes, including pasta, subs, and salads. The lasagna is a particular standout, layered with rich meat sauce, creamy ricotta cheese, and melted mozzarella. And the garlic knots? Soft, chewy, and drenched in garlic butter – a must-order appetizer. The atmosphere at Papa Joe’s is casual and family-friendly, making it a great place to bring the kids. They also offer takeout and delivery, so you can enjoy their delicious food in the comfort of your own home. Located on Main Street, Papa Joe’s is easy to find and a welcome addition to the Spencerport food scene.
The Pizza Stop
If you prefer a different kind of pizza, perhaps you would like The Pizza Stop. This place offers a variety of pizzas and is focused on the carry-out experience. You can order from this spot easily and quickly. They have a focus on friendly service and quick pickup times. This location can be found right off of Route 31.
Sweet Treats and Cafes
No culinary tour is complete without a stop for something sweet. Spencerport has several options to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Abbott’s Frozen Custard
Let’s start with a Spencerport staple, Abbott’s Frozen Custard. While it may seem silly to include a shop like this in an article focused on the food of Spencerport, for the residents it is an integral piece of what makes Spencerport the special place that it is. For those who do not know, Abbott’s Frozen Custard is a Rochester-based chain of frozen custard shops. While not unique to Spencerport, the town’s residents certainly make their Abbott’s a favorite spot, especially in the summertime. Located conveniently along the Erie Canal near the lift bridge, a trip to Abbott’s is a wonderful way to finish a day.
Coffee at 23 Main
And, when you want to relax and enjoy a coffee and perhaps a baked good, there is Coffee at 23 Main. This cafe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. You can relax with a latte and a pastry. Their coffee is locally roasted, and their pastries are baked fresh daily. They also offer a selection of sandwiches and salads for a light lunch. It’s a great spot to catch up with friends, get some work done, or simply enjoy a quiet moment. The cafe is located on Main Street, and the ambiance is enhanced by the natural light from the large windows, making it a cozy and welcoming space. They feature different specialty coffee drinks each month and often have art from local artists on display as well. This location also features a small retail shop where you can find different items to give as gifts for friends and family.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
While the restaurants mentioned above are all well-established and popular, Spencerport is also home to a few hidden gems that are beloved by locals. These are the places that you might not find in a guidebook, but are definitely worth seeking out. (Note: It’s crucial to research specific establishments here and add relevant details. Since I lack real-time access to current information, I’m providing a placeholder.)
Local Food Truck
One example could be a local food truck specializing in local ingredients. Food trucks have exploded in popularity in recent years, and Spencerport has its fair share. Look for a truck that specializes in cuisine featuring ingredients from local farms. The menu might change regularly based on what’s in season, but you’re guaranteed to get fresh, flavorful dishes. It’s a great way to support local farmers and enjoy a unique culinary experience. Check local social media groups for food truck schedules and locations.
Family-Owned Ethnic Cuisine
Another option could be a small family-owned restaurant that features ethnic cuisine. This restaurant might be a hole-in-the-wall serving authentic ethnic dishes. It’s the kind of place where the food is made with love and the portions are generous. Look for dishes that are hard to find elsewhere and be prepared to be surprised and delighted. These types of restaurants are often found in strip malls or on side streets, so keep your eyes peeled.
Local Mexican Restaurant
Finally, if you are looking for something with a little bit of a kick, try a local Mexican restaurant. This location provides a lot of great options that are sure to bring a smile to your face.
Dining with a View
One of the best things about Spencerport is its location along the Erie Canal. Fortunately, some restaurants take full advantage of this scenic setting.
Restaurant with Canal View
A Restaurant with Canal View offers stunning views of the canal. Imagine enjoying a delicious meal while watching boats glide by and the sun setting over the water. The ambiance is relaxed and romantic, making it a perfect spot for a special occasion or a memorable evening out. The menu features dishes prepared with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Be sure to ask for a table with a view when you make your reservation.
Conclusion
Spencerport, NY, is more than just a pretty face. Its food scene is diverse, delicious, and constantly evolving. From casual family restaurants to cozy cafes to hidden gems serving up unique culinary experiences, there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger, a slice of New York-style pizza, a sweet treat, or a farm-to-table meal, you’ll find it in Spencerport. The next time you’re looking for a culinary adventure, skip the big cities and head to this charming canal town. Explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide, discover your own favorites, and experience the delicious side of Spencerport. Support local Spencerport businesses and come with an appetite. You won’t regret it! This culinary tour is sure to please anyone.
