New Buffalo, Michigan, a charming lakeside escape nestled on the shores of Lake Michigan, beckons with its pristine beaches, welcoming atmosphere, and a surprising array of culinary delights. Beyond the sun-kissed sands and the gentle lapping of waves, a world of flavors awaits, promising a delightful journey for every palate. From casual bites enjoyed with sandy toes to elegant dinners overlooking breathtaking sunsets, New Buffalo and its surrounding areas offer a dining experience as memorable as the vacation itself. This guide is your passport to navigating the vibrant food scene near New Buffalo, ensuring you savor every delicious moment of your getaway. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, hearty comfort food, or an innovative culinary adventure, prepare to discover a tapestry of tastes that will leave you wanting more. So, unpack your appetite and get ready to explore the best food near New Buffalo!
New Buffalo Mainstays: Iconic Restaurants
No culinary exploration of New Buffalo is complete without experiencing its iconic restaurants, the established favorites that have woven themselves into the fabric of the community. These are the places where generations have gathered, creating memories over delicious meals and warm hospitality.
One such cornerstone is The Stray Dog Bar & Grill, a legendary establishment known for its laid-back atmosphere and crowd-pleasing menu. This is your quintessential casual hangout, perfect for grabbing a bite after a day at the beach. Think juicy burgers, crispy fries, and refreshing drinks served with a side of good times. While they are known for their casual dining, the quality of the food, along with the service, makes them an iconic staple of the town. The pricing is moderate, making it a great choice for families and groups. What sets The Stray Dog apart is its enduring appeal, its ability to bring people together in a relaxed and friendly setting, making it a true symbol of New Buffalo’s welcoming spirit.
Another must-visit is Redamak’s, a family-owned institution that has been serving up its famous “Butter Burgers” since 1975. This no-frills establishment focuses on one thing and does it exceptionally well: crafting incredibly delicious, melt-in-your-mouth burgers. Simplicity is key here, with each burger made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere is casual and lively, and the prices are incredibly reasonable, making Redamak’s a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. The legacy of Redamak’s as a family ran business and their simple, yet delicious menu, makes them a perfect iconic destination in New Buffalo.
Finally, Brewster’s Italian Cafe is a more recent addition to the iconic list, yet no less important. Brewster’s offers amazing italian fare made from fresh ingredients. You will enjoy the quaint atmosphere and friendly staff as you sit down for a nice lunch or dinner. Known for their pizzas, pastas and extensive wine list, you won’t be disappointed. Their pricing is moderate, making it accessible to most.
Casual Bites & Quick Eats in New Buffalo
Sometimes, all you need is a quick and satisfying meal to fuel your adventures. Luckily, New Buffalo boasts a selection of casual eateries perfect for grabbing a bite on the go or enjoying a relaxed lunch.
For sandwich aficionados, Nancy’s New Buffalo is a must-visit. This charming spot offers a wide array of sandwiches, salads, and soups, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From classic deli sandwiches to creative wraps, there’s something to please every palate. Nancy’s is perfect for packing a picnic lunch for the beach or grabbing a quick and healthy meal during your explorations. The price range is moderate, and the atmosphere is bright and welcoming.
When a sweet craving strikes, Oink’s Dutch Treat is the place to be. This beloved ice cream parlor is a New Buffalo institution, serving up homemade ice cream in a variety of flavors. From classic vanilla to unique creations, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Oink’s is the perfect spot to cool down on a hot summer day and indulge in a delicious treat. The prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is fun and festive.
For a classic American craving, Patties Diner is the place to be! Patties offers a classic diner menu, made from scratch! With homemade soups and desserts, friendly service and an overall cozy atmosphere, Patties Diner will not disappoint. Patties is great for families and friends alike and offers a wide variety of food that will please even the pickiest eaters!
Dining with a View: Waterfront Restaurants
New Buffalo’s stunning waterfront location provides the perfect backdrop for a memorable dining experience. Imagine savoring delicious food while gazing out at the sparkling waters of Lake Michigan, the sun setting on the horizon. These waterfront restaurants offer not only exceptional cuisine but also breathtaking views that will elevate your meal to a whole new level.
The Terrace Room at the Marina Grand Resort offers elevated dining with a beautiful view of the marina. Enjoy upscale American Cuisine at a fine-dining establishment. The Terrace Room is perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. Their prices are on the higher side, but the experience is well worth it for a special night.
Bentwood Tavern delivers a more casual experience while still showcasing amazing views. With outdoor seating available, enjoy burgers, wraps, salads and more while taking in the views. Be sure to stay and enjoy the sunset as well! Bentwood Tavern is great for families, friends and groups looking for a good meal and a fun experience.
Venturing Beyond: Worth the Short Drive
While New Buffalo itself offers a diverse culinary scene, some hidden gems are located just a short drive away in neighboring towns. These restaurants are worth the extra few minutes of travel, offering unique culinary experiences and unforgettable flavors.
In the charming town of Three Oaks, Journeyman Distillery stands as a testament to craft spirits and exceptional dining. Housed in a historic factory, Journeyman offers a unique atmosphere and a menu that showcases locally sourced ingredients. Their distillery offers tours and tasting as well. From delicious pizzas to creative entrees, there’s something to please every palate. It’s a perfect place to try amazing local craft spirits and enjoy an amazing atmosphere.
Just north of New Buffalo in Union Pier, Whistle Stop Cafe is a fantastic local spot that you should visit. They offer a fun diner experience, from classic breakfasts to sandwiches and more! They are loved for their fast, friendly service and delicious food. Be sure to check out Whistle Stop Cafe in Union Pier!
Hidden Gems
There are a few restaurants that might not be as well-known, but are amazing places to eat in New Buffalo. Here are some Hidden Gems you should be sure to checkout!
Skip’s Other Place is a local favorite! They have a menu filled with pizza, tacos, quesadillas, salad and much more! Skip’s is a New Buffalo staple that serves the community year round with quality food. Known for its generous portions and great prices, Skip’s Other Place is a great spot for a casual meal. Located right near the beach, be sure to check out Skip’s Other Place next time you are in New Buffalo!
Alberto’s Cafe is an authentic mexican restaurant that is beloved by the local community. With a wide variety of classic dishes, you will be pleased with the flavors and portions served. From Tacos to Burritos and more, you will get an authentic Mexican Meal at Alberto’s! Alberto’s is a great hidden gem that you should make sure to visit.
Conclusion
New Buffalo, Michigan, is more than just a beautiful lakeside destination; it’s a culinary haven waiting to be explored. From the iconic restaurants that have defined the town’s food scene to the hidden gems that offer unique and unexpected flavors, New Buffalo and its surrounding areas offer a dining experience that caters to every taste and preference. Whether you’re seeking a casual bite with a view, an elegant dinner for a special occasion, or a taste of local specialties, you’ll find it all within easy reach. So, embark on a culinary adventure, discover your own favorite spots, and savor the delicious flavors of New Buffalo! Let your taste buds guide you, and you’re sure to create unforgettable memories that will last long after your vacation is over. Bon appétit!
