Nestled along the stunning shores of Lake Michigan, and a convenient getaway from the bustling streets of Chicago, New Buffalo, Michigan, has long been celebrated for its pristine beaches, charming boutiques, and relaxed atmosphere. But beyond the sun-kissed sand and picturesque harbor, lies a culinary landscape that’s just waiting to be explored. New Buffalo offers a surprising array of dining experiences, from casual beachfront eateries to sophisticated restaurants perfect for a special occasion. It’s a town where the scent of lake-fresh fish mingles with the aroma of sizzling burgers, where you can find everything from handcrafted pizzas to elegantly plated farm-to-table creations. So, leave your beach towel for a few hours, and prepare to indulge in the delicious side of this lakeside gem.
New Buffalo, MI boasts a diverse culinary landscape sure to satisfy any palate, offering everything from fresh seafood and farm-to-table delights to classic American fare and international flavors. This guide will explore some of the best dining options the town has to offer, ensuring your visit is not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. Whether you’re craving a quick bite after a day on the water, a romantic dinner with a view, or a family-friendly feast, New Buffalo has something to tantalize your taste buds. Let’s dive in and discover the best food in New Buffalo MI.
Casual Bites and Family Favorites
Sometimes, the best meals are the ones that are simple, satisfying, and shared with loved ones in a relaxed setting. New Buffalo has plenty of options that fit the bill, perfect for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a family-friendly outing. These establishments offer a comfortable atmosphere, delicious food, and a welcoming vibe that makes them local favorites.
One iconic spot is Stray Dog Bar & Grill. With its lively atmosphere, extensive menu, and prime location, Stray Dog is a staple for both locals and tourists. They are known for their delicious burgers, generously sized sandwiches, and refreshing drinks. The outdoor seating area is a great place to enjoy a summer evening, making it a popular spot for after-beach gatherings or a casual dinner with friends. The restaurant’s name and theme add to its charm, creating a fun and memorable experience for everyone.
Then there’s Redamak’s, a New Buffalo institution. This establishment is steeped in history and famous for its legendary burgers. Redamak’s has been serving up delicious, no-frills burgers for generations. Expect a simple menu, a lively atmosphere, and a taste of New Buffalo’s past. The restaurant has a loyal following, and for good reason – the burgers are consistently delicious, and the atmosphere is pure Americana. A trip to New Buffalo isn’t complete without stopping at Redamak’s for a burger and a side of fries.
No vacation is complete without a sweet treat, and Scoops Ice Cream has you covered. Offering a wide variety of ice cream flavors, sundaes, and other frozen delights, Scoops is the perfect place to cool off on a hot day. The shop is family-friendly, and the staff is always happy to help you choose the perfect flavor. Whether you’re craving a classic vanilla cone or a decadent sundae, Scoops has something to satisfy your sweet tooth. It’s the ideal spot to end a perfect day in New Buffalo, MI.
If you’re in the mood for pizza, Patellie’s Pizza is a great option for a quick and easy meal. They offer a variety of pizzas, from classic cheese to specialty pies, and they also have salads, appetizers, and other Italian favorites. Perfect for a casual lunch or dinner, Patellie’s Pizza is a reliable choice for a satisfying and affordable meal. You can order for takeout or dine in, making it a convenient option for families and groups.
Fine Dining and Special Occasions
For those seeking a more sophisticated dining experience, New Buffalo offers a selection of upscale restaurants that are perfect for a romantic dinner, a special celebration, or a memorable evening out. These establishments boast elegant ambiance, exquisite cuisine, and impeccable service.
The Terrace Room at The Harbor Grand is a true gem, offering breathtaking views of Lake Michigan and a refined dining experience. The restaurant’s elegant atmosphere, coupled with its stunning location, makes it a popular choice for special occasions. The menu features contemporary American cuisine, with an emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The Terrace Room also boasts an extensive wine list, allowing you to perfectly pair your meal with a complementary vintage. Dining here is a truly unforgettable experience.
Another excellent choice for upscale dining is Bentwood Tavern. This restaurant is known for its refined American cuisine and its commitment to using local, seasonal ingredients. The menu changes regularly to reflect the freshest produce and seafood available, ensuring that every dish is bursting with flavor. The atmosphere is sophisticated yet comfortable, making it perfect for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal with friends. Bentwood Tavern also has a well-curated wine list and a selection of craft cocktails.
Skip’s Other Place is another great choice for those seeking a more refined experience. It’s an upscale restaurant specializing in fish and steak, with a variety of menu options to suit any palate. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors.
Dining with a View
There’s something truly special about enjoying a meal with a stunning view of the water. The gentle lapping of the waves, the shimmering sunlight reflecting on the lake, and the fresh, salty air all combine to create an unforgettable dining experience. New Buffalo has several restaurants that offer breathtaking waterfront views, allowing you to savor your meal while taking in the beauty of Lake Michigan.
As mentioned previously, The Terrace Room at The Harbor Grand offers unparalleled views of Lake Michigan. Its prime location right on the water allows diners to enjoy panoramic vistas while indulging in delicious cuisine. Whether you’re watching the sunset over the lake or simply enjoying the peaceful atmosphere, dining at The Terrace Room is a truly special experience.
[Insert a description of another restaurant in New Buffalo with lake or harbor views here, aiming for at least 100 words. Be sure to include its name, location, type of food, and what makes the view special from that location. For example, if it has outdoor seating overlooking the harbor, describe that experience.]
Breakfast and Brunch Delights
Start your day off right with a delicious breakfast or brunch at one of New Buffalo’s charming cafes and diners. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast to fuel your adventures or a leisurely brunch with friends, you’ll find plenty of options to satisfy your appetite.
David’s Delicatessen is a local favorite, offering a wide variety of breakfast and lunch options. From classic breakfast sandwiches and omelets to deli-style sandwiches and salads, David’s has something for everyone. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, making it a great place to grab a quick bite or linger over a cup of coffee. David’s is known for its fresh ingredients, generous portions, and friendly service.
[Insert a description of another New Buffalo breakfast/brunch spot here, aiming for at least 100 words. Be sure to include its name, location, type of food, and what makes it special. For example, if it has a unique breakfast item or a cozy atmosphere, highlight those aspects.]
Drinks and Nightlife
After a day of exploring New Buffalo, you might be looking for a place to unwind and enjoy a refreshing drink. The town has a variety of bars and pubs that offer a lively atmosphere and a selection of craft beers, cocktails, and other beverages.
Local Pour is a popular spot for craft beer enthusiasts. With a wide selection of local and regional brews on tap, Local Pour is the perfect place to sample some of Michigan’s finest beers. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a great place to relax with friends. They also offer a selection of wines and spirits.
As mentioned earlier, Stray Dog Bar & Grill also has a lively bar area that’s perfect for enjoying a drink and socializing. The bar offers a wide variety of beers, wines, and cocktails, and the atmosphere is always buzzing. Whether you’re looking for a place to watch the game or simply relax and enjoy a drink, Stray Dog is a great option.
Local Specialties and Must-Try Dishes
When visiting New Buffalo, be sure to sample some of the local specialties and must-try dishes. The area is known for its fresh Lake Michigan fish, as well as its locally produced craft beers and wines.
Fresh Lake Michigan fish, such as perch and whitefish, is a must-try for seafood lovers. Many restaurants in New Buffalo offer these locally caught fish prepared in a variety of ways, from pan-fried to grilled. Be sure to ask your server about the daily specials and the freshest catches.
Michigan is also known for its thriving craft beer and wine scene. Be sure to sample some of the local brews and wines during your visit. Many restaurants and bars in New Buffalo offer a selection of Michigan-made beverages. Consider visiting a local winery or brewery for a tasting experience.
Tips for Dining in New Buffalo
To make the most of your dining experience in New Buffalo, here are a few tips to keep in mind:
Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season. Many restaurants in New Buffalo are popular and can get crowded, so it’s best to make a reservation in advance to avoid disappointment.
Parking can be limited, especially during the summer months. Be prepared to walk a bit or consider using a ride-sharing service.
Check restaurant websites or social media pages for hours of operation and menus. Hours can vary depending on the season, so it’s always a good idea to check before you go.
Support local businesses. New Buffalo is home to many locally owned and operated restaurants, so be sure to support them during your visit.
Conclusion
New Buffalo, MI, offers a vibrant and exciting food scene that’s sure to delight any food lover. From casual beachfront eateries to sophisticated restaurants, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide and discover your own favorites. The variety of food in New Buffalo MI is waiting to be discovered! So pack your bags, bring your appetite, and plan your culinary adventure to New Buffalo today! You are sure to find something to write home about!
