New Buffalo, Michigan, a gem nestled along the shores of Lake Michigan, beckons with its pristine beaches and captivating sunsets. But beyond the allure of sun-kissed shores, a vibrant culinary landscape awaits discovery. This charming town, easily accessible from Chicago and other Midwestern hubs, has evolved into a haven for food enthusiasts seeking a diverse and satisfying experience. If you’re planning a getaway, prepare to indulge in the delights of the local restaurants, cafes, and eateries that contribute to New Buffalo’s unique character.
This guide will take you on a delicious adventure through New Buffalo, highlighting the finest dining establishments, uncovering hidden treasures, and recommending must-try dishes that make this town a true destination for those who appreciate good food. From casual spots perfect for a quick bite to elegant restaurants ideal for a special occasion, New Buffalo offers a culinary journey for every palate. Get ready to experience the incredible food in New Buffalo, MI.
Grab-and-Go Goodness: Casual Eats in New Buffalo
Sometimes, all you need is a quick, satisfying meal that doesn’t require a lot of fuss. New Buffalo understands this need, offering a variety of casual dining options perfect for grabbing a bite before hitting the beach or fueling up after a day of exploring.
The Stray Dog Bar and Grill
A New Buffalo staple, The Stray Dog Bar and Grill, is known for its lively atmosphere and reliably delicious American fare. This spot is always buzzing, particularly during peak season, and for good reason. Their menu is packed with crowd-pleasers, from juicy burgers and crispy fries to flavorful sandwiches and fresh salads. The rooftop deck offers stunning views of the harbor, making it the perfect place to enjoy a casual lunch or dinner while soaking in the New Buffalo vibe. Their perch tacos are a must-try. Located right in the heart of town, it’s the ideal spot for a quick and satisfying meal. You’re sure to find something to please everyone on their expansive menu. The reasonable prices make it a great option for families.
Redamak’s
No visit to the area is complete without a stop at Redamak’s. Okay, it’s technically just outside of New Buffalo, in neighboring New Buffalo Township, but it is essential to the New Buffalo food experience. Famed for their butter burgers, they have a long history with local residents and tourists alike. It is a no-frills, casual stop, but you will find some of the best simple burgers you can find. Make sure to bring cash!
Brewster’s Italian Cafe
For those craving a taste of Italy, Brewster’s Italian Cafe offers a relaxed and inviting atmosphere alongside classic Italian dishes. From homemade pasta and flavorful pizzas to hearty sandwiches and delicious salads, there’s something to satisfy every craving. Brewster’s is known for using fresh, high-quality ingredients, resulting in dishes that are both authentic and satisfying. They also boast a selection of Italian wines and beers, making it the perfect place to unwind after a busy day. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner or a casual lunch with friends, Brewster’s Italian Cafe is a solid choice in the landscape of food in New Buffalo, MI.
Oink’s Dutch Treat
No trip to New Buffalo is truly complete without a stop at Oink’s Dutch Treat, even if it’s just for the photo op! They have been serving up ice cream for almost 50 years in New Buffalo. They have a wide variety of flavors to choose from and are perfect for a refreshing treat on a hot day. It is a must for the kids when looking for food in New Buffalo, MI!
Elevated Eats: Fine Dining Experiences in New Buffalo
For those special occasions or simply when you’re in the mood for a more refined dining experience, New Buffalo boasts several restaurants that offer exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and sophisticated ambiance. These establishments are perfect for creating lasting memories and indulging in culinary masterpieces.
Bentwood Tavern
Located within the Marina Grand Resort, Bentwood Tavern offers a sophisticated dining experience with a focus on seasonal ingredients and innovative dishes. The menu features a variety of options, from fresh seafood and prime cuts of meat to creative vegetarian dishes. The restaurant’s elegant décor and attentive service create a memorable atmosphere, perfect for a romantic dinner or a celebratory gathering. The view of the harbor from the dining room is a delightful bonus. Bentwood Tavern is dedicated to providing guests with an exceptional culinary experience that celebrates the best of what the region has to offer. Consider trying their seafood risotto or the pan-seared scallops; reservations are highly recommended. Bentwood Tavern certainly helps elevate food in New Buffalo, MI.
The Terrace Room
The Terrace Room, nestled inside the Harbor Grand Hotel, offers guests a truly exceptional dining experience. The ambiance is relaxed, but elegant with beautiful views of the harbor. The restaurant focuses on using seasonal and locally sourced ingredients to create a memorable meal for guests. The cocktails are made with fresh ingredients and are thoughtfully prepared to compliment the meal.
Taste of New Buffalo: Local Flavors and Hidden Gems
Beyond the well-known restaurants, New Buffalo is home to several hidden gems and local favorites that offer a unique taste of the region. These establishments are often family-owned and operated, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere alongside delicious, home-style cooking.
Nancy’s
Nancy’s Bar and Grill is a long-standing New Buffalo tradition. They are known for their great, no frills food and very reasonable prices. Nancy’s is a favorite amongst the locals. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, with a mix of regulars and tourists alike. The burgers, fish and chips, and daily specials are all highly recommended. For affordable, delicious food in New Buffalo, MI, Nancy’s is the place to go.
Waterfront Dining: Restaurants with a View
The unique location on Lake Michigan provides numerous options for waterfront dining. These establishments offer stunning views that will make your experience with food in New Buffalo, MI that much more special.
The Terrace Room
Already listed above, The Terrace Room earns a second mention for their fantastic food and excellent views of the harbor.
Family-Friendly Options: Eats for the Entire Family
When you are looking for restaurants that are great for the whole family, New Buffalo has many to choose from.
The Stray Dog Bar and Grill
Once again, The Stray Dog Bar and Grill makes the list. They have a large menu with kid-friendly options. The casual atmosphere makes it a fun stop for the family.
Oink’s Dutch Treat
As mentioned before, you cannot go to New Buffalo without a stop at Oink’s! Great place to take the kids after dinner!
New Buffalo Farmers Market
Although not a restaurant, the Farmers Market (seasonally) offers an excellent opportunity to sample and purchase local produce, baked goods, and other culinary delights. This is a great way to support local farmers and artisans while experiencing the freshest flavors of the region. Check for the dates and times of the market during your visit. You can often find food trucks or prepared food vendors at the market as well.
Conclusion: A Culinary Adventure Awaits
From its stunning lakefront location to its diverse culinary offerings, New Buffalo, MI, truly has something to offer every food lover. Whether you’re seeking a quick and casual bite, a sophisticated dining experience, or a taste of local flavor, you’re sure to find it in this charming lakeside town.
The restaurants mentioned in this guide are just a starting point for exploring the exciting food in New Buffalo, MI. Be sure to venture off the beaten path and discover your own hidden gems. With its commitment to fresh ingredients, innovative cuisine, and warm hospitality, New Buffalo is sure to leave you with a lasting impression – and a satisfied appetite.
So, the next time you’re planning a trip to New Buffalo, be sure to bring your appetite and prepare to discover a delicious side of this charming lakeside town. From casual lunches overlooking the harbor to elegant dinners celebrating local flavors, New Buffalo offers a culinary experience that is both memorable and rewarding. Embrace the opportunity to indulge in the diverse and delightful food scene of New Buffalo, MI, and create unforgettable memories that will last long after you’ve left the shores of Lake Michigan.
